Could a Bag Tax Go Statewide in Maryland?
Some state and county officials say yes. What do you think of paying for grocery bags?
Prince George’s and Howard counties are among the jurisdictions statewide that are exploring following in Montgomery County's footsteps and imposing a tax on plastic bags used at retail establishments. However, Baltimore County is one region that does not appear to be going along.
In Maryland, most counties need state legislative approval to pass a tax; Baltimore city and county, and Montgomery County are the only jurisdictions that don't need legislative approval, according to the Baltimore Sun.
Baltimore County Executive Kevin Kamentez has “no interest in pursuing a bag tax,” said county spokeswoman Ellen Kobler.
Carroll County commissioners also said the bag tax wouldn’t come to fruition in their area.
“Any new tax or tax hike is wrong in this economic climate,” said commissioner Haven Shoemaker. “When did it become government's job to determine what type of shopping bags people should use? In my opinion, that would be the nanny state run amok.”
Similarly, commissioner Robin Frazier said it should be up to the free market to adjust consumer behavior.
“When citizens and businesses decide that plastic bags are worse for the environment than they are useful and affordable, they will stop using them and the market will adjust,” she said.
State officials say they expect a movement to continue to make the bag tax mandatory statewide, following the momentum created by Montgomery County, the first jurisdiction in the state to implement a bag tax, which went into effect Jan. 1.
“I think there will be a continued strong push for statewide action,” said Del. Alfred Carr, D-Montgomery. “I think there’s a growing awareness among the public and legislators. … People realize the extent to which these plastic bags are ending up as litter and fouling the waterways.”
It is estimated the five cents people pay to use plastic bags in Montgomery County will generate $1.5 million in revenue for the first year--money officials said would be used for water quality programs.
Carr said that for the past three years he has been the lead sponsor of a statewide bag fee bill, which he said has stalled in committee each year.
A March Washington Post editorial blamed the bill’s 2010 failing on “election-year jitters” among lawmakers hesitant to approve a new tax.
Carr said he likely won’t be the lead sponsor on a similar bill this year since the measure passed in Montgomery, his district, but he said several groups were pushing for the measure.
Those include the Maryland League of Conservation Voters, which has made a plastic bag tax as one of its top priorities for the 2012 legislative session. Its proposal also includes using the revenue for water quality improvement efforts.
The idea of taxes on grocery bags also has its opponents.
The website bagtheban.com, a project of the plastic bag manufacturer Hilex Poly, said these types of taxes are a threat to jobs at bag manufacturing companies.
The site also says that reusable bags could breed bacterial contamination, if not regularly cleaned with soap and water, a claim backed by Charles Gerba, a professor at the University of Arizona.
Gerba’s study, published recently in the International Association for Food Protection's Food Protection Trends magazine, found that intestinal bacteria like E. coli flourish in unwashed reusable bags.
There has also been some consumer backlash.
One Calverton resident told Patch recently: “I don’t feel that we should have to pay for bags for our groceries or anything else,” she said. “That should be something that we all should get free."
Montgomery’s bag tax follows the bag tax enacted in Washington, D.C., which is in effect for businesses that sell food or alcohol, according to The Washington Post.
In Howard County, County Executive Ken Ulman has asked environmental protection staff members to research the concept of a bag tax and offer him options to consider, according to county spokesman Kevin Enright.
Prince George’s County officials are actively pursuing the tax. State Sen. Paul Pinskey and Del. Barbara Frush, both Democrats from Prince George’s, have said they plan to seek legislative approval to allow county officials to levy the tax.
Bill
7:04 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012
Why are politicians always trying to tax something. Instead of trying to tax everything, lets cut their pay checks. It seems like ever time you turn around, they are getting a raise. Just like the bull with SHEILA DIXON, commit a crime and still keep her 70 some thousand dollar pension. That's the Government for you.
Emily Lowe
10:17 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012
It's always amusing to me how eager store clerks are to put my purchases in a bag -- even when what I'm buying (a purse, a basket) could very easily serve as its own bag. Whether or not you're an environmentalist, it's just wasteful to use something once and throw it away.
It would be great if people would realize this on their own and take steps to stop using disposable bags -- then we wouldn't need to fight about it in the legislature. Realistically, though, I doubt consumers will change their habits unless they feel the economic pinch of a tax.
janet
1:02 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
OK, then no bags, walk out with your merchandise in your hands. That way it will be hard to tell the shop lifters from paying customers.
Helen Schlessinger
9:26 am on Saturday, January 7, 2012
I agree that shops are quick to bag any item - even those easy to carry or stick in your purse. If someone wants to carry a reusable bag to fill with groceries, that's great. Does anyone care what a burden this tax will be on families? We are a family of six that has chosen to make ends meet on one income. My oldest three are boys eating everything in sight. Grocery shopping is a two cart ordeal!
Ron Wise
12:07 pm on Saturday, January 7, 2012
Unless I missed it, no one mentioned recycling, whether it be to manufacture furniture or deck boards or to carry back to the store to be refilled. If we did have to pay a tax to receive new bags with our purchases, you would have to use 20 bags to spend an extra dollar. I can only presume that the debate is over freedom of choice. Whose reasoning is better than another's? Both sides have good points. My wife and I have already bought several cloth bags...now, if we can only remember to use them!
Michael Ernest
5:41 pm on Saturday, January 7, 2012
I use plastics bags for garbage and paper bags to put my recycle stuff in.
Do they want me to put raw garbage in my trash can? Ugh!
CAW21227
6:34 am on Sunday, January 8, 2012
More baloney from the government. When I was a kid there were no plastic bags, everything you bought went into a paper bag. We recycled (I don't think that word even existed in the 50's and 60's) them for book covers, trash bags, crafts, wrapping paper etc. Then the government said they were bad for the environment, too many trees were being cut down so we had to go to plastic bags. Now the plastic bags are bad. Even the cloth bags are bad because now it's thought that they harbor bacteria. I picture the "government" as a room with a big table with a bunch of people sitting around saying "what can we tax next?, how can we get another dollar out of the citizen". "They" are always coming up with things that are bad for you or the environment. I for one am tired of being duped. This subject should cause people to think about the case for less government.
Ron Wise
10:32 am on Sunday, January 8, 2012
CAW, I remember those days. We did use the brown bags for all of those things. I think that we, as a nation, still remembered how we had to pull in our belts for WWII and the Depression before that. I wasn't yet born in the 1930s, but the old saying was: Use it up, wear it out.
Make it do or do without.
People seemed to be so much more conscientious about waste back then. Now-a-days, the USA has a world-wide rep as wasters.
Harry Frank
3:44 pm on Sunday, January 8, 2012
It seems to me that if it's such a problem why not put a 4 cent deposit on the bags and pay it back to the customer when they are returned. You sure won't find any laying around.